Events

(Update) Absa Cape Epic: Evans and Knox penalised for unfair advantage

By Press Office · 426 comments

The race for the Absa African jersey took a dramatic turn Thursday when Kevin Evans and Max Knox (FedGroup Itec) were given a one-hour penalty for taking an illegal shortcut.

They had been leading the race for the special jersey – for the first all-African team in the Absa Cape Epic – after Thursday’s 88km stage four, but other riders complained after Evans apparently took a short cut across an uphill switchback.

The Commissaires Panel said in a statement that a protest had been made to the race office: “… it was stated that a member of team 13 (Kevin Evans) deviated from the course (took a shortcut) and in doing so gained an unfair advantage over other riders.

“Review of Go-Pro camera footage from the rider immediately behind the rider in question, as well as footage from team 13’s own Go-Pro (attached to the bicycle of the accused rider) confirms that the incident occurred, and that an unfair advantage was gained.”

Evans and Knox were apparently planning to appeal the sanction, but if it stands it means they would be fifth in the race for the distinctive red jersey and nearly 50 minutes behind. With only three stages to go, this would put them out of the race.

Scott Factory Racing’s Matthys Beukes and Gert Heyns inherited the category lead after FedGroup Itec were penalised. Their overall time is 19:51.09,2, with Erik Kleinhans and Nico Bell (RECM) just five minutes back.

The top all-South African team in the women’s category remains sixth-placed Yolande de Villiers and Ischen Stopforth (SasolRacing), but best local bet for a podium is third-placed Theresa Ralph, riding with Swede Jennie Stenerhag.

Thursday also saw local Definitive Bikes pairing Shan Wilson and Adrian Enthoven’s chances of winning the Master’s category suffer a setback when they were finally overhauled by Dutchman Bart Brentjens and Brazil’s Abraao Azevedo (BETCH.nl Superior Meerendal). The foreigners won the stage in 4:04.32,0 – nearly eight minutes ahead of the South Africans on the day – and are now nearly four minutes ahead overall.

South African television personality and much-decorated rider Andre Mclean continued to dominate the Grand Masters category with Austrian teammate Heinz Zoerweg (CycleLab Toyota) and are now nearly an hour ahead of Doug Brown and Switzerland’s Barti Bucher (Meerendal Songo Specialized 4).

South Africa’s hopes of a win in the mixed category were dashed by the withdrawal Thursday with breathing problems of Cherise Stander, riding with Theo Blignaut for RECM Mixed, but Cape Town’s Nizaam Essa and his Austrian partner Christina Kollman had moved up to third by the end of Thursday’s stage. Stander and Blignaut had been lying second.

Update (28 March 2014) – From the Absa Cape Epic

An appeal by Kevin Evans and Max Knox (FedGroup Itec) against their one-hour penalty for taking an illegal shortcut in the Absa Cape Epic failed Thursdaynight.

The penalty effectively ended their pursuit of the red Africa jersey – for the first all-African team to finish – and they appeared to be taking it easy on Friday’s stage five.

Other riders complained after Evans apparently took a short cut across an uphill switchback on stage four.

The Commissaires Panel said in a statement that a protest had been made to the race office: “… it was stated that a member of team 13 (Kevin Evans) deviated from the course (took a shortcut) and in doing so gained an unfair advantage over other riders.

“Review of Go-Pro camera footage from the rider immediately behind the rider in question, as well as footage from team 13’s own Go-Pro (attached to the bicycle of the accused rider) confirms that the incident occurred, and that an unfair advantage was gained.”

Video footage of the incident

Related posts

Comments

Meezo

Mar 27, 2014, 5:51 PM

 

Post proof. What's an "Oli"?

 

Seems like Scott (beukes and heyns) launched this appeal.

 

I don't believe you.

 

Oli = Oliver Munnik

Stretch

Mar 27, 2014, 5:54 PM

I am sure the Brandon Stewart fine was related to his "doping" cloud that is Hanging over him... as for the shortcut.. Even 50 is OK in my book.. Let's wait and see

NotSoBigBen

Mar 27, 2014, 5:58 PM

I wonder if sometimes the decision to make an 'appeal' may be decided on by the team management rather than by the individual athlete/s or maybe I'm just talking poofie?

GoLefty!!

Mar 27, 2014, 6:01 PM

Post proof. What's an "Oli"?

 

Seems like Scott (beukes and heyns) launched this appeal.

 

I don't believe you.

 

If Evans says Scott racing launched the appeal then he would know better than a .....person on the internet since he would have been informed who lodged the protest.

 

Can't see why a back marker would care as they would have nothing to gain and would'nt be up here anyway.

Only someone with something to gain would lodge a protest that gains them an advantage and that would be appear to the 2nd placed team

GoLefty!!

Mar 27, 2014, 6:03 PM

I am sure the Brandon Stewart fine was related to his "doping" cloud that is Hanging over him... as for the shortcut.. Even 50 is OK in my book.. Let's wait and see

 

 

look, at least they didn't take a wrong turn again...

Cellar

Mar 27, 2014, 6:07 PM

I wonder if sometimes the decision to make an 'appeal' may be decided on by the team management rather than by the individual athlete/s or maybe I'm just talking poofie?

 

I have been part of teams and have appealed to UCI refs before. It was a joint decision. I've also been involved when we as riders wouldn't let the team appeal. But in my experience, it's a joint decision.

TALUS

Mar 27, 2014, 6:37 PM

1. Brandon should not be near there - it can just turn into a PR nightmare. 2. He should tell them to go to hell - R150k is ridicilous. What are they gonna do? Lock him up, ban him?

bassasdaindia

Mar 27, 2014, 6:41 PM

is this R150k fine confirmed ?

Guest Karma

Mar 27, 2014, 6:45 PM

1. Brandon should not be near there - it can just turn into a PR nightmare. 2. He should tell them to go to hell - R150k is ridicilous. What are they gonna do? Lock him up, ban him?

 

Hit and miss.

TALUS

Mar 27, 2014, 6:49 PM

 

 

Hit and miss.

50% is pass
Cassie

Mar 27, 2014, 7:00 PM

I find this strange as during the prologue I think it was Either team Bulls or Meerendal Songo Specialised that also cut a switchback. The move could have saved them 2 seconds and it was televised yet no protest.

 

Yip, was going to comment exactly that! It was Bulls (Platt) Sauser...

No wonder all the Pro's carry GoPro's (I found it ironic - they shave evry gram off the bike, yet they put a camera on...)...it is for that exact reason...proof of infringements...what has this race come to??

Cassie

Mar 27, 2014, 7:05 PM

R150,000 for touching a water bottle is a little stupid don't you think.

 

Sort of like a R150,000 speeding fine for doing 140 in a 120 zone

 

punishment befitting the crime??

 

Hey, its the EPIC...they need to make some money??? Or will thsi go to CSA coffers perhaps? :ph34r:

Eugene Oppelt

Mar 27, 2014, 7:06 PM

 

 

Yip, was going to comment exactly that! It was Bulls (Platt)...

No wonder all the Pro's carry GoPro's (I found it ironic - they shave evry gram off the bike, yet they put a camera on...)...it is for that exact reason...proof of infringements...what has this race come to??

 

Using technology smartly for 'fair play' in a real prestigious world - class sporting event

Works for me

Cassie

Mar 27, 2014, 7:13 PM

Was the alleged shortcut within the boundaries of the route ? I am assuming that the route isn't continuously taped ?

 

Just trying to think to myself that if it was a 5m "shortcut" then its more cutting the corner than taking a shortcut. And if so, then isn't that line choice more than deliberate cheating?

 

Havent seen the footage so working on a lot of assumptions

 

Very interesting comment....when the track is not marked with tape...when is it legal to leave the route / course / jeeptrack? / dirtroad / whatever...It surely will be matter of just choosing another (lesser travelled) line? 5m over a distance of 100+km?? C'mon...

Cassie

Mar 27, 2014, 7:17 PM

Can I say this.. but all this about 5m is bloody childish. . 5km./10km yes fine that's cheating.. but 5m ag no man.

 

Lance went off road during that one tdf and was commended for great handling skills.. (yes I know he isn't a good example)

 

Yesterday's highlights package showed several riders joining the route again from behind one of the water points...surely they "stole" at least 10 -20m ...are they also getting 1hr penalties??

TALUS

Mar 27, 2014, 7:18 PM

If it really is only a few metres, it is BS. There must be more to it than that.

tunariaan

Mar 27, 2014, 7:22 PM

Seems to be more than 5m

So someone tunes him when he takes a shortcut and then he swears at the oke..nice specially from a pro

The should give him more for being skelm

Guest Karma

Mar 27, 2014, 7:30 PM

Seems to be more than 5m

So someone tunes him when he takes a shortcut and then he swears at the oke..nice specially from a pro

The should give him more for being skelm

 

Bold Statement...especially without facts.

 

Wait for press release guys.

Spoke101

Mar 27, 2014, 7:48 PM

My view on the situation: If you have? and you probably have, ever been stuck behind someone on a section of ST then you know the feeling. :cursing: Now for the average "Joe" this is not to much of a problem, but for the Pro's it's different. This is there job, they not there because they enjoy it, want to ride Epic, or have fun. It's there bread and butter. The Pro riders in this country put on a brave face for the public but behind the scenes tend to hate each others guts for various reasons and can hold a proper grudge. One reason being that they all fighting for the same piece of pie. 1: a job, 2: the win, 3: sponsors, etc. and it doesn't help that they are all as competitive as HELL. So lets just say that rider 1 and rider 2 weren't riding right behind one another in a group of 10 riders on a section of ST and someone in the front attacked and the group started to split. Rider 1 & 2 have the strength to go with the attack but rider 2 is stuck behind other riders who don't. So here is where it gets ugly, what do you do? I have been in this situation, both the giving and receiving end, tempers fly out the window when you mix a bunch of every competitive people who are hot, tired, going 110% and would rather be somewhere else you get an ear full of some very colorful language. I deal with it in various ways eg. cut the corner of a switchback, or pull over and allow others to pass, but then I'm not racing for my job.

tunariaan

Mar 27, 2014, 7:57 PM

Did the route lap today or how did the slow riders get to the front?

Gen

Mar 27, 2014, 8:15 PM

I think Fedgroup should tell them to go get stuffed.. and get dr evil to make next yrs addition reaaal special. ;)

Guest Smimby

Mar 28, 2014, 5:16 AM

Now if only they could impose simular actions for littering.

 

Ie. Adrianne. On TV opening a bar and spitting out that little bit off the wrapper torn off with her teeth to open it.

Gen

Mar 28, 2014, 5:25 AM

So my kids overheard us discussing this whole gemors, and my eldest said.. aah so they've had all the previous stages to out ride Fedgroup and get the African jersey out on route but need to cry about a couple of meters of corner cutting to get it.. My son is 12, he also said it sounds like stuff the mommies of some of the kids in his school would do to get their kids ahead. :whistling:

rouxtjie

Mar 28, 2014, 5:28 AM

So my kids overheard us discussing this whole gemors, and my eldest said.. aah so they've had all the previous stages to out ride Fedgroup and get the African jersey out on route but need to cry about a couple of meters of corner cutting to get it.. My son is 12, he also said it sounds like stuff the mommies of some of the kids in his school would do to get their kids ahead. :whistling:

Rules are rules....and good call by epic. They just need to apply it consistently. Dumb move by Fedgroup and they got caught....end van prent

Gen

Mar 28, 2014, 5:31 AM

Rules are rules....and good call by epic. They just need to apply it consistently. Dumb move by Fedgroup and they got caught....end van prent

 

That's the big issue here.. They are not consistent with it AT all.. if they were then Songo should be 1hour behind too. :whistling:

 

Any how.. it's Friday after all and I only have until 10 to play along with the Friday madness. :w00t:

Add a comment

You must log in to comment