Events

Tokai and Silvermine to remain closed to the public

By Press Office · 762 comments

In the interest of public safety, as well as for the protection of the environmental integrity of the Silvermine and Tokai sections of Table Mountain National Park (TMNP), park management decided that these two areas will remain closed to the public until further notice.

TMNP management understands that users are eager to access these areas, however they remain very sensitive and unsafe, and public use of these areas are off limits due to:

  • Smouldering and burning vegetation still needs to be extinguished and flare ups will occur as stumps and roots burn.
  • Standing trees that have been burnt or damaged by the fire are extremely dangerous as they continue to come down in the area.
  • Recently burnt veld (as well as adjacent areas) is hazardous as the fire will have burnt roots underground and foot falls may cause serious injuries.
  • Unstable slopes may result in rock falls
  • Winds and rain may exacerbate the danger with respect to falling trees, branches, rock falls and mudslides
  • Hazardous clear-felling operations of the burnt plantation trees are underway by Cape Pine
  • Disturbance to surviving animals
  • Burnt areas are sensitive as windblown seeds can be damaged and the first emerging plants can be killed by accidental trampling
  • Disturbance to sensitive erodible soils

The closure of the burnt areas will be continually assessed and reopening will only be considered once all safety and environmental issues have been addressed. For some areas this may take between six to twenty four months.

TMNP management and staff would like to assure the public that their focus is to secure the areas for the public’s safety and to as quickly as possible rehabilitate the affected sites for future use.

Please assist us by being patient and please remain out of all burnt areas while mother nature heals herself.

Comments

i24

Mar 16, 2015, 11:11 PM

Interesting. From http://www.sanparks.org/conservation/park_man/

 

"Stakeholders are further invited to attend public information sessions at one of the venues listed below and comment on aspects relating to these plans."

 

I just registered at:

 

http://www.sanparks....ms/reg_form.php

 

Maybe I can be an "insider" too ;-)

Shebeen

Mar 17, 2015, 3:16 AM

Interesting. From http://www.sanparks.org/conservation/park_man/

 

"Stakeholders are further invited to attend public information sessions at one of the venues listed below and comment on aspects relating to these plans."

 

A bunch of times/dates of meetings between 2nd and 7th March are listed. Did anybody hear of these dates being advertised? Were they ever brought to the attention of activity permit holders, or TokaiMTB? Did anybody go to any of these events? The dates coincide with the time of the fire, did the meetings actually happen?

 

It almost feels like SANPARKS want to take over our mountain and do what they think is best for us with as little interaction with, or interference from, the residents of Cape Town as possible. After the price increase débâcle last year, I am loosing what little confidence I had left in SANPARKS.

I'm guessing those meetings all got cancelled, with fire ranging at the time
tubed

Mar 17, 2015, 4:48 AM

i must have been asleep at the time, but who really thought it was a good idea to make it a national park in the first place? Is more of a tourist attraction surrounded by a city and an anomaly in the SANParks portfolio. Cape nature would seem a more suitable custodian to me.

Precisely, the whole management plan though is an attempt to gate areas to produce revenue, which is totally at odds with what I believe was the original intent when the heads of agreement were entered into.

 

Sanparks have imposed their vision on something which should never be managed the way it is. The practical outworking is in conflict with every person be it with trail shoes, an mtb, a picnic basket or a dog leash looking up at the mountain and wondering why they cant just access that part of the peninsula.

 

Ok, too early to get heated. Bring on the Epic again. Bikefun! 

Flowta

Mar 17, 2015, 6:19 AM

Precisely, the whole management plan though is an attempt to gate areas to produce revenue, which is totally at odds with what I believe was the original intent when the heads of agreement were entered into.

 

Sanparks have imposed their vision on something which should never be managed the way it is. The practical outworking is in conflict with every person be it with trail shoes, an mtb, a picnic basket or a dog leash looking up at the mountain and wondering why they cant just access that part of the peninsula.

 

Ok, too early to get heated. Bring on the Epic again. Bikefun! 

 

This is 100%

GLuvsMtb

Mar 17, 2015, 10:52 AM

Probably not, not such a big Fransman fan, neither Tony E - I wont be betting on them organising themselves soon, unless you have inside info. They are irrelevant imo.

 

But then I am not such a fan of Sanparks either as you can see.

 

What I will say is that it is a matter of time before the majority of the facilities previously enjoyed by all Capetonians and others become priced out of range as the golden guineafowl is expected to keep producing for Pretoria.

Already it is impossible for the majority of citizens to think of visiting Cape Point, Tokai picnic area, Hottentots Huisie, Boulders etc. That position wont go unnoticed and I agree with it.

 

I think if you read all 118 pages of the proposed management plan for TMNP, which is currently out for comment, then you wont find a single reference to mountain bikes, so I wouldn't be placing too much hope on Sanparks plans for mtb in the near future. If it happens, it will happen in spite of them.

 

http://www.houtbayheritage.org.za/tmnp-draft-mgmt-plan%202015.pdf

Remember that political tenure is short term. What if the ANC manage to bus in enough voters to take control (or split control) over the City? The interesting bit is that if this was in Europe, Canada or the US, the mountain would probably be privately owned.
Slapsock

Mar 19, 2015, 7:59 AM

Remember that political tenure is short term. What if the ANC manage to bus in enough voters to take control (or split control) over the City? The interesting bit is that if this was in Europe, Canada or the US, the mountain would probably be privately owned.

Sanp is run from pretoria so essentially ANC run, so if ANC took over cape town again it wouldn't make any difference to the current position, moving it under CoCT could only be an improvement. At least you have direct access to the decision makers

DJR

Mar 19, 2015, 10:57 AM

The management of Tokai and the greater Table Mountain National Park, is simply is not a political issue, and we should not make it one. To see darker motives and agendas behind what was done, or not done, is no more than conspiracy theory, not based in fact.

 

As much as I hate the fact that SANParks do not listen much to the locals and take our money without ploughing it back into our beloved mountain, the reality is that it will probably be best to deal with the devil we know. Yes, I also would like the decision makers to be based in Cape Town and to have direct input from locals into things that impact on them. I also think they have made mistakes, but they have done some very good things since they took over - Cape Point revamp, Chappies Toll, Boulders, come to mind. Some things were done well, but seem to not work well - Hoerikwaggo Trail not used much. Some things were handled poorly - Tokai and mountainbiking, I think. For the future, they have some great plans, for Tokai among others. They are also following a sound and rigorous process in formulating their plans, as opposed to doing bits on an ad hock basis.

 

I think the City of Cape Town is not in a position to manage Table Mountain National Park effectively. They do not have the expertise or the staff to do it.   

 

As an alternative, Cape Nature is perhaps the best positioned to run Table Mountain National Park. They have the expertise, the staff and the track record running several reserves successfully. But do not think for a moment that they don't have their own problems or that they will automatically do a better job. What I like about Cape Nature is that they are based in the Western Cape and that their funds stay here. Whether they will listen to the locals any better than SANParks, is another question.

 

Privatize the whole of Table Mountain National Park? I don't like the idea! I mistrust big business just as much as government to do the right thing.

 

In my opinion, working with SANParks is the best way forward for mountainbiking in Table Mountain National Park. The days when we were free to do what we felt like, ride where we wanted and build wherever we wanted, whatever we wanted, are long gone, and will not return. A formal structure, and working within that formal structure, is the only answer. (Keep in mind that I find this difficult myself, as I am inclined to want to rebel and do my own thing, so I don't say the above easily.) 

Goosebay

Mar 19, 2015, 11:26 AM

Sanparks is driven by political agendas - so whoever is at the helm influences the direction.  When the whole public participation process started re Tokai deplantation (some then still called it deforestation), the decision makers only pretended to listen - and spent truck loads of money doing so, money that could have built trails.  At one point they flew 6 delegates down from Pretoria to smile at those who thought they might be listened to. 

 

So I am not sure whether Sanparks with their current leadership is healthy for mountain bikers - some creative thinking needs to be done!

 

Maybe a brainstorm evening - to get as many ideas as possible - just one really good idea is needed.

Eddy Gordo

Mar 19, 2015, 11:27 AM

Well said, however I dont think privateers will be allowed to operate. One of the reasons as to why the mountains around the peninsula are national parks was/ is to prevent anyone from setting up developments of sorts or coining in on the mountain. The fact that there are indigenous fynbos etc is they key reason. 

 

I agree that cape nature should take over the custodian duties.

 

Can you imagine what the mountains would look like if it werent a national park?

 

 

most likely somthing like this 

http://cache1.asset-cache.net/gc/154820217-rochina-a-favela-in-rio-gettyimages.jpg?v=1&c=IWSAsset&k=2&d=No4f%2BZImTSBwCAcboBaFFLXzZce4f%2Bc10XJmRw7W79KeBfcwBK0EeVTtIxmcR%2F8p%2FchpZSftWK7NOqQrFOgBOQ%3D%3D

Captain Fastbastard Mayhem

Mar 19, 2015, 11:37 AM

Sanparks is driven by political agendas - so whoever is at the helm influences the direction.  When the whole public participation process started re Tokai deplantation (some then still called it deforestation), the decision makers only pretended to listen - and spent truck loads of money doing so, money that could have built trails.  At one point they flew 6 delegates down from Pretoria to smile at those who thought they might be listened to. 

 

So I am not sure whether Sanparks with their current leadership is healthy for mountain bikers - some creative thinking needs to be done!

 

Maybe a brainstorm evening - to get as many ideas as possible - just one really good idea is needed.

That is precisely what we as TokaiMTB are doing. 

Goosebay

Mar 19, 2015, 11:39 AM

When we were at the Night harvest and you looked across the valley to the other side - there was a defined building line - except the shack area.  Look at Knysna and a few other places.  Political will is a funny thing - it morphs and shapes to whoever is at the top.

 

We can be thankful though that TM is a world heritage site - it will help in the long run. 

 

But like DJR said - big business is also not the answer - we need ideas.  I read a publication put out by Scott a while ago (2009) on how some of the Swiss and French bike parks started - and often it is the case where it is one person driving the process - either for the love of biking - or money.  In this case it was the love of biking - and he needed to get the whole community involved for it to work.  Look where those bike parks are now. 

 

Hard work - the thing is - who is up to that, and how can he or she be supported.  There are some local SA examples...........

Goosebay

Mar 19, 2015, 11:42 AM

That is precisely what we as TokaiMTB are doing. 

 

Those of us outside the loop have no idea what TokaiMTB is doing - get a mail list going so that we can be reliably informed, and offer help and ideas. 

Capricorn

Mar 19, 2015, 11:42 AM

Well said, however I dont think privateers will be allowed to operate. One of the reasons as to why the mountains around the peninsula are national parks was/ is to prevent anyone from setting up developments of sorts or coining in on the mountain. The fact that there are indigenous fynbos etc is they key reason. 

 

I agree that cape nature should take over the custodian duties.

 

Can you imagine what the mountains would look like if it werent a national park?

 

 

most likely somthing like this 

http://cache1.asset-cache.net/gc/154820217-rochina-a-favela-in-rio-gettyimages.jpg?v=1&c=IWSAsset&k=2&d=No4f%2BZImTSBwCAcboBaFFLXzZce4f%2Bc10XJmRw7W79KeBfcwBK0EeVTtIxmcR%2F8p%2FchpZSftWK7NOqQrFOgBOQ%3D%3D

prime for Urban Assaults! ;)

Flowta

Mar 19, 2015, 11:46 AM

Those of us outside the loop have no idea what TokaiMTB is doing - get a mail list going so that we can be reliably informed, and offer help and ideas. 

:clap:  :clap:

dirtypot

Mar 19, 2015, 11:47 AM

Those of us outside the loop have no idea what TokaiMTB is doing - get a mail list going so that we can be reliably informed, and offer help and ideas. 

 

Ping Cpt Armpies!  Come in Cpt!!

Your soothing tones to the masses are needed.

Captain Fastbastard Mayhem

Mar 19, 2015, 11:54 AM

Those of us outside the loop have no idea what TokaiMTB is doing - get a mail list going so that we can be reliably informed, and offer help and ideas. 

100%

 

At the moment it's all a bit - how can I say - chaotic. 

 

We're working on several things at the moment, but none of them have firm timelines. apart from our project charter, which we want to be finished asap but no later than end April. Which, IMO, is something that we need before we can say that we're doing XYZ, otherwise there aren't any deliverable terms and so on. 

 

The fire HAS stuffed things up a bit for the moment (short term) but right now we're working to get back into the park to assess the damage, and at the same time getting our structures sorted so that we can prep for the fundraising to start in earnest. That, however, won't start until we have timelines from Parks as to when we can start rebuilding. Which we're pressuring them for.

 

We're also finalizing our project charter, which will be made public relatively shortly. That will work side by side with the EMP and Rationalisation project.

 

It all hinges on timelines though.

 

BTW - mailing list. 

 

We can't get a list from Parks that is specific to MTB, unfortunately (going to carry on trying) So I am thinking of ways to get it inclusive and easily accessible. Facebook, for all its usefulness, just DOESN'T work for stuff like that. 

 

how about - for the moment - ping me at mylesmayhew2409@gmail.com and give me your mail addresses so that I can collate them. Distribute this mail address to your mates and get them to send me a mail, or add their addresses to your mail so that when the newsletters DO start coming out (shortly) I at least have a group of contacts to send it to.

 

Feel free to send it to as many people as you need to.  

Captain Fastbastard Mayhem

Mar 19, 2015, 11:55 AM

prime for Urban Assaults! ;)

Bahahaha! Yeah, indeed. UA through IY, anyone?

(Deon)

Mar 19, 2015, 11:56 AM

Those of us outside the loop have no idea what TokaiMTB is doing - get a mail list going so that we can be reliably informed, and offer help and ideas. 

Sign up. Twitter, Facebook, Hub, Newsletter, Website..

 

@AMA_TokaiMTB

facebook/TokaiMTB

TokaiMTB.co.za

 

Obviously since the fire we are crawling around gathering our senses again.. think we've all taken a bit of a knock - so news for now is a bit sparse but the plans presented at the AGM is still on track, being that most of the work in the immediate future will be done at the table now that trails are closed.

Captain Fastbastard Mayhem

Mar 19, 2015, 11:59 AM

Sign up. Twitter, Facebook, Hub, Newsletter, Website..

 

@AMA_TokaiMTB

facebook/TokaiMTB

TokaiMTB.co.za

 

Obviously since the fire we are crawling around gathering our senses again.. think we've all taken a bit of a knock - so news for now is a bit sparse but the plans presented at the AGM is still on track, being that most of the work in the immediate future will be done at the table now that trails are closed.

yeah, there's this (thanks D) but I also want to get a proper mailing list / newsletter out every now and then. Some people just aren't on these platforms, and we know how social media works - FB timelines are based on your previous interaction with that group, so if it's far down the list, you never see it  :cursing:

(Deon)

Mar 19, 2015, 12:00 PM

100%

 

At the moment it's all a bit - how can I say - chaotic. 

 

...

 

Ah. Smiles has beaten me to it... happy anniversary dude.

Goosebay

Mar 19, 2015, 12:02 PM

 

how about - for the moment - ping me at mylesmayhew2409@gmail.com and give me your mail addresses so that I can collate them. Distribute this mail address to your mates and get them to send me a mail, or add their addresses to your mail so that when the newsletters DO start coming out (shortly) I at least have a group of contacts to send it to.

 

Feel free to send it to as many people as you need to.  

Thanks will do

(Deon)

Mar 19, 2015, 12:02 PM

yeah, there's this (thanks D) but I also want to get a proper mailing list / newsletter out every now and then. Some people just aren't on these platforms, and we know how social media works - FB timelines are based on your previous interaction with that group, so if it's far down the list, you never see it  :cursing:

C'mon, are you not on the newsletter database?? 

 

I was thinking blog too but there has to be someone running all these platforms.

Captain Fastbastard Mayhem

Mar 19, 2015, 12:02 PM

Ah. Smiles has beaten me to it... happy anniversary dude.

Fanks bro!

Captain Fastbastard Mayhem

Mar 19, 2015, 12:03 PM

C'mon, are you not on the newsletter database?? 

 

I was thinking blog too but there has to be someone running all these platforms.

I put my hand up...

 

EDIT: I mean, I'll do it. I have the time. 

Add a comment

You must log in to comment